Rich & Gooey Pies

Pecans, Dutch chocolate, creamy buttermilk…our sweetest and most decadent group of pies are sure to please any crowd. These pies also travel really well and hold up great at cookouts.

Pecanchopped pecans and browned butter…mmmmm |
$26 |
Pecan (with bourbon)same as the original, but spiked with bourbon |
$29 |
Butterscotch Pecanan extra sweet twist for the serious dessert lover |
$26 |
Chocolate Pecanlike the traditional pecan with melted chocolate mixed in |
$26 |
Chocolate Chessmade with Dutch chocolate and will satisfy the chocoholic |
$26 |
Coconut Chesssweet, gooey, and full of flaked coconut. |
$26 |
Lemon Chesslemon zest and lemon juice for a bright flavor |
$26 |
German Chocolatea milk chocolate pie base with pecan and coconut topping |
$26 |
Buttermilk Pietangy and creamy and excellent when topped with fresh berries |
$26 |
Derby Piea sweet pie, laced with chocolate chips and pecans |
$26 |
Derby Pie (with Bourbon)same as the original, but spiked with Kentucky bourbon |
$29 |
Fresh & Fruity Pies

Each pie is filled with homemade fruit fillings and topped with flaky lattice or crunchy crumble crust. We believe they are most flavorful when served at room temperature.

A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble)A mashup of our two most popular pies - Apple Crumb and Bumbleberry - this one is sure to please |
$28 |
Apple Crumba popular apple variation that adds a sweet crunch |
$28 |
Auntie Nae's Appleapples, cinnamon and coated with our caramel sauce |
$28 |
Old Fashioned Appleclassic…we use cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger |
$28 |
Apple Cranberry Crumble (Sept.-Dec.)tart cranberries and crunchy pecan crumble |
$28 |
Bumbleberryour mixed berry pie is loaded with strawberries, blueberries, blackberries and raspberries - no surprise it's a big fan favorite. |
$28 |
CrumbleberryOur popular bumbleberry pie topped with our brown sugar oat crumble |
$28 |
Cherrywe use red tart cherries to make this filling from scratch - and it became famous after being featured in Southern Living Magazine |
$28 |
Cherry Crumbleour famous red tart cherry filling topped with our signature almond-coconut butter crumble |
$28 |
Wild Maine Blueberrywe use tiny wild blueberries so every bite is packed with berries |
$28 |
Blackberrymarion blackberries fill this classic pie to the brim and spark the nostalgia of days gone by. |
$28 |
Southern Peachbecause peaches and the south belong together |
$28 |
Peach Crumbletopped with our almond coconut crumble |
$28 |
Blackberry Peach Crumblemarion blackberries and juicy peaches topped with our brown sugar oat crumble |
$28 |
Blueberry Peachwild blueberries and juicy peaches and just a touch of cinnamon - the perfect combo |
$28 |
Strawberry (Apr.-Sept.)the perfect summertime treat |
$28 |
Strawberry Peach (Apr.-Sept.)strawberries and peaches are brought to life with a hint of basil - all the flavors of summer in one pie |
$28 |
Strawberry Rhubarb (May-July)very popular when in season…sweet and tart all in one pie |
$28 |
Pumpkin (Sept.-Dec.)light, fluffy, and flavored with all the fall spices we love |
$28 |
Sweet Potato (Sept.-Dec.)a classic fall favorite |
$28 |
Cool & Creamy Pies

Creamy homemade puddings fill a variety of crusts and all flavors are topped off with homemade whipped cream. All of these pies require refrigeration.

Atlantic Beach Pie (Apr.-Sept.)A true North Carolina recipe, this creamy lemon pie in a saltine crust (yes that's right!) is eaten on the Carolina coast after a seafood dinner. |
$28 |
Chocolate Creamdutch chocolate melted into our homemade pudding…for serious chocolate lovers |
$28 |
Chocolate Espresso Creamsilky chocolate espresso pudding topped with espresso whipped cream in our pastry crust (also can be made in our chocolate cookie crust! |
$28 |
Coconut Creamflaked coconut throughout a vanilla pudding in a pastry crust |
$28 |
Frozen Margarita PieCreamy, zesty lime filling in a salted pretzel crust, spiked with tequilla and orange liqueur. |
$31 |
Frozen NutellaRich and smooth chocolate hazelnut goodness in a chocolate cookie crust. |
$28 |
Key Limereal key lime juice gives this pie its delicious tart flavor |
$28 |
Lemon Meringuetart lemon filling with fluffy meringue baked to golden perfection |
$28 |
Banana Creamfresh bananas, our homemade vanilla pudding in a pastry crust |
$28 |
Nutty Monkeychocolate cookie crust, fresh bananas, peanut butter pudding & chocolate chips |
$28 |
Peanut Butter Creampeanut butter pudding in a chocolate cookie crust |
$28 |
Frozen Peanut Butter Piethis one has a fan base because it's amazing…and gluten free! |
$28 |
Chocolate Peppermint Cream (Dec.)mint chocolate cookie crust with our rich chocolate pudding |
$28 |
Frozen Lemonade Pie (June-Aug.)the perfect addition to your summer cookout |
$28 |
Pumpkin Cream (Sept.-Dec.)creamy pumpkin spice pudding in a ginger snap crust topped with brown sugar whipped cream |
$28 |